A blessing occurred in Brewster, Massachusetts, yesterday. A 90-year-old man who lived every day of his life exactly as he chose died quickly and peacefully, before his choice – or his awareness of his choice – could be stolen from him. Charles Ross, Sr., born January 25, 1922, died freshly scrubbed (he’d just had a shower), in the care of one of his favorite nurses at about 9:45 a.m., October 10, 2012. The end came very quickly, within the 15 minutes or so between the time of the nursing home’s urgent call to me and my running through the facility’s automatic doors.
He hadn’t seemed quite himself for the previous week or two, though there were no vital-sign statistics to back up my intuition that something was just, well, off. His voice was softer, he was more likely to be sleeping in his wheelchair when I came through the door and there was a stronger sense of depression around the fringes of the inordinate optimism through which he typically looked at the world. One telling example occurred about a week ago, when he complained that he’d missed having corn on the cob this summer. “Well, now you’ve got something to look forward to next year,” I said (yes, I seem to have inherited that envelope-pushing optimism). “I’m not so sure about that,” was his uncharacteristically dour response.
Then, from Stage Left, entered Rex the Wonder Dog, the last significant cast member in the comic drama Dad and I have been living the last 4-1/2 years, and Dad’s spirits ticked up. It was just one week before Dad died when I walked into his room with my new four-legged buddy, a 2-year-old flaxen-haired beauty with a disposition so sweet and calm that, in his presence, one can see the possibility that, in one of his many previous incarnations, the current Dalai Lama was, perhaps, a golden retriever. During a subsequent visit, Rex and I sat outside with Dad and, with his hand on Rex’s head (and, referring back to the absence he’d seen in my life since my old pal Bart’s premature demise) Dad made the statement, “Well, now you have your dog.” At the time, I almost laughed at the solemnity of that statement and Dad’s delivery. In retrospect, though, I see it almost as a checklist item: Chuck has his dog, he’s not alone. Done.
So, now Dad is gone, at least in body. That line between here/not-here is just so distinct. Just five minutes ago, I caught myself in the pattern of checking the clock to see how much morning work time I had left before I headed out the door for my regular 11 a.m. visit. And, sometime in the next six months or so, that transition will be made even more distinct, when Dad’s ashes will be spread in Cape Cod Bay as he wished, near the little fishing center of Rock Harbor, where he loved to park his old Mercury Grand Marquis and watch the charter boats make their way in and out the channel. That area is, essentially, the same stretch of coastline where I once ran with Bart and now send Rex running after tennis balls, just a couple miles of marsh and shallow water away.
I wondered at Dad’s choice, originally – wouldn’t he prefer the company of other former Marines in the veteran’s cemetery, or that of the golfers along the course of his old country club? After all, he hated the cold, damp northeast winds that blow across the bay’s gray water in the winter, and he had no particular fondness for either swimming or beaches. But maybe he knew that, in the sand flats of Cape Cod Bay, he’d still get to enjoy his son enjoying his dog on a regular basis. A man who knew how he wanted to spend his life also knew how he wanted to spend the time that followed that life – and he couldn’t think of a better place to do so.
Rest in peace, Dad. You loved. You were loved. You will continue to be loved. And Rex and I will see you on the flats.












October 11, 2012 at 9:38 am10
Thank you for your lovely eulogy, kind and caring and merciful, to say goodbye (after surely a thousand goodbyes). Thank you for sharing your path with us these several years. I’m so glad your father did not suffer too many of the indignities of very advanced age, and that you are at peace with his passing, at least to some extent.
October 11, 2012 at 9:38 am10
I’m so sorry. We spend such a lot of time wondering wondering wondering what is going to happen and then in an instant we know. Best wishes to you.
October 11, 2012 at 9:38 am10
Glad to hear that your dad went quickly and thrilled that you have Rex with you on your new road. Thank you for sharing your journey, you’ve helped lighten the load many caregivers carry.
October 11, 2012 at 9:38 am10
I want to thank you for sharing your journey with us all these years. Your dad was a lucky guy in so many ways – his passing was peaceful and quick – his son was a dedicated caregiver for him. Your honesty in sharing the caregiving experience has been very meaningful – it’s not always a pretty picture. You can be proud of yourself for the gift you gave to your dad and the gift you gave to yourself. My very best wishes for you in the transition out of the caregiver role. I hope you will continue to chronicle the journey.
October 11, 2012 at 9:38 am10
A blessing indeed. May my own father be so lucky. Thank you for your postings, I have gotten a lot out of them. My thoughts go with you as you embark on the path of grieving and memory.
October 11, 2012 at 9:38 am10
I believe there is such a thing as a good death, and I’m quietly glad that your father had one. Godspeed to him and peace to you, Chuck.
October 11, 2012 at 9:38 am10
Every time I see there is an update to your blog I pause before I click to open the message. My father is 88 years old and I have found comfort, frustration, laughs, anger, and acceptance in your writings. Thank you for sharing you journey.
October 11, 2012 at 9:38 am10
Condolences to you, Chuck. I know what you have been through in the past few years has been mind boggling. Strength to you to carry on in the aftermath. Your father was extremely lucky to have you.
October 11, 2012 at 9:38 am10
And enjoy your dog … I know he will be a great comfort.
October 11, 2012 at 9:38 am10
Chuck,
What a moving tribute to your dad. Your love for him and respect is reflected in every single word. I cried thinking of my own dad in his final months. How lucky you were to have each other
October 11, 2012 at 9:38 pm10
Chuck, thank you very much for sharing your journey with all of us over this time. We’ve gotten to know you and your father. You’ve helped me in my journey with those I love…thank you again.
October 11, 2012 at 9:38 pm10
The change in your father is one that I’ve seen before in hospice patients. Something changes in the last days. It’s difficult to put your finger on it but it’s sort of a sense on the part of the dying person that “check out” time is nearing. Thanks for taking us on this journey for better and worse.
October 11, 2012 at 9:38 pm10
As many tears as I shed while reading this lovely eulogy, I’m sure they’re nothing compared with how many you shed while writing it. When my parents died, we knew Dad’s time was very close — and so did he, even though he was only 62. Mom’s passing at 75 was very sudden, but like your father, she seemed to fade away a bit in the couple of weeks before that final evening.
I truly believe that we all, given enough years, reach a stage when death is a relief — the time for a graceful exit from a life well-lived. (Well, maybe not always graceful. My grandfather, age 89, died in the middle of a game of gin rummy with some physician friends. My contention to this day is that he got a bad hand and decided to check out.)
October 11, 2012 at 9:38 pm10
amazing Chuck. I can’t help but think how tuned in you were to every nuance in Charlie’s life. The conversation we had just a day before he died, eerie almost. This gift of caregiving your Dad was hard earned and a time of redemption and forgiveness for both of you, although your awareness that it was indeed a gift, is now probably more keenly felt. Love you and loved him
October 11, 2012 at 9:38 pm10
Thank you! A good death, a good dad and a good son.
October 12, 2012 at 9:38 am10
Chuck, I’ve been reading your posts since the NYT New Old Age blog pointed me in your direction a couple of years ago. Caring for my own frail 95 year-old dad in my home for three years and now visiting him in a nearby nursing home, I related to every one of your experiences. I knew that this column would come one day and dreaded seeing it. But, as you have so often, you illuminated this sad event with your clear-eyed compassion and affectionate voice. I give you my heartfelt condolences. I can only hope for such a good death, with his daughters at this side, when my dad’s time comes. You have been a role model for me in many ways and I will think of all your wise and funny words as I continue walking next to my dad for however much time we have. Thank you.
October 12, 2012 at 9:38 am10
I can only echo what everyone else here has already said. Thank you for sharing your life with us. Your Dad had the best son anyone could ask for. Best wishes to you, Chuck.
October 12, 2012 at 9:38 am10
I, too, started to read your blog several years ago in an attempt to not feel so all alone as I took on more and more care for my mother. I read a big portion of the blog in one sitting – to catch up on your journey- and felt such sadness as I saw the turning of your posts from updates on your new house and life in New England to the all consuming business of taking care of your dad. I was devastated for you when I read about the death of your old dog. It seemed so unfair that he would be taken from you when you were giving so much of your life to your dad.
I knew this day would come for you and sometimes wondered if it already had when you did not post for awhile. That your father went in such a relatively peaceful, graceful and easy way at the end is such a blessing for both of you. I am so thankful that you have a new dog in your life now and I pray that he will help you through the transition in your life- back to letting it really be YOUR life again.
You gave your father the gift of your love and care in his last years and you gave yourself the gift too. You should be very proud of yourself.
I hope to have as much patience and love as I continue to help my mom get to the end of her life.
October 12, 2012 at 9:38 am10
Chuck, last night I cried for sadness, for joy, and for relief.
I send a heart full of appreciation to you and to your Dad for sharing your journeys with us. For taking your time.
Your compassionate and often courageous insights were my main nighttime “only child caregiver” human comforter, from my discovery through Jane’s NYT New Old Age mention. You have your own folder in my Outlook email.
My parents passed a year ago, at 92 and 96, within six weeks of each other. My Golden, “Desi” (Beckwith’s Heart’s Desire), had joined us one month in 2006 before my mother’s stroke and the house of cards fell down. She patiently kept good company through much of what you chronicled: hospitals, moves, and warzone alarums and excursions. Desi is now 13 and is a wonderful bridge from those caregiving years to the months afterwards. Shedding layers of attention, focus, and care. Ignoring the phone. Hey, she’s just happy for sleeping in her own bed. And she wants you to know that she agrees with your incarnation theories.
I am so glad you have Rex and that your Dad got to meet him. It’s a mystery. And it’s all right, somehow. I wish you peace and springtime. Your kharma bank is full.
Please continue to let us know how you’re doing.
Thank you from Bellevue, Washington,
Sophie
October 12, 2012 at 9:38 am10
I will miss you and your dad. You’ve been wonderful companions on my own journey in elder care.
October 13, 2012 at 9:38 am10
Ken and I have been blessed to have you and Charlie as our neighbors. I am grateful that Charlie left this world quickly and peacefully. I am glad he was able to share a neighborhood party at our house last May as a result of your diligence in obtaining transportation –not an easy job as it turned out. I’m so pleased that Charlie recognized you as his hero. I have appreciated the humor and candor of your blog and know that you have touched other people’s lives through it. And I am especially happy you have Rex the wonder dog. Peace be with you my friend.
October 13, 2012 at 9:38 am10
You have written a loving, lovely and warm farewell through this blog. I thank you for the story of your experience and wish you all the best.
October 13, 2012 at 9:38 pm10
Thank you for your blog. Helpful to those of us that are too caring for loved ones who are struggling with old age and the loss of independence. God’s peace be with you. Job well done.
October 14, 2012 at 9:38 am10
Too bad your father missed the Cardinals’ amazing recovery in the Friday night game with the Nationals; he would have loved it. Thanks for sharing your journey with your dad.
October 15, 2012 at 9:38 am10
Rest in peace, Dad. And Chuck, may you now be as good to yourself as you were to Dad.
October 15, 2012 at 9:38 pm10
I hope your Dad’s presence on the flats brings you comfort and peace. My mother is “buried” on a stretch of beach she used to love, near family and friends, after I cared for her for a year. I love to go and say hello, and know she is loving the sun and the warm sand. My dog of many years helped me through it all, and got a whole new esprit after my Mom was gone. Hope Rex does, too, and brings you years of happiness and joy. Thanks for your posting, and with all best wishes and condolences.
October 16, 2012 at 9:38 am10
Blessings, and gratitude to you for sharing your path these last few years with so many of us who are also on the path, in one way or another. I am so glad that your dad met Zeke, and I do believe that knowing that you had a dog in your heart again was part of your dad’s ‘choice’ to let go of life. I am amazed at how the bond of giving and receiving care and affection can continue and evolve over the years between the birth of a child and the death of the parent. Wishing you rest and peace and healing in this next chapter of your story, with Zeke to remind you of the importance of daily walks and tennis balls by the ocean, no matter what the weather (around and inside of you.)
October 17, 2012 at 9:38 pm10
Sending condolence, as well as many thanks for sharing your experience. Your writing has been of great comfort as I deal with my own caregiving challenges. Best wishes to you as you continue your journey.
October 18, 2012 at 9:38 pm10
‘My sympathy at the loss of your Dad. Thank you for sharing your life; your Dad………… yourself………… with your readers. I found your blog through the “New Old Age Blog” in the New York Times; and………… in my trying, from 1,800 miles away, to help #3 of my siblings – (who live there locally) – care for our two elderly parents………… your blog has been a “refuge”………… for me, BIG-TIME………… of plain-speaking honesty; realism (even when it “hurt”!!); very welcome common sense; and refreshingly *non*-delusional thinking, (i.e., I just can’t even begin to TELL you, you know!!) THANK YOU for – through the years – *so kindly* HELPING others, like me, online………… whom you didn’t even know. You’re a g.o.o.d. man, Chuck.
October 19, 2012 at 9:38 am10
Thank you, Chuck — and thank you, Charlie. Sharing the journey, you lightened our journeys. Your blog was a blessing for me caring for my husband.
October 19, 2012 at 9:38 am10
I just found your blog today through the NY Times and was stuck so much by how it mirrored many of my own experiences. I just wish I had found your blog earlier. I was laid off suddenly and surprisingly almost 4 years ago in what turned out to be a blessing for it afforded me the time to become my parents’ caregivers. Yes it was difficult financially and emotionally and frustrating oh so many times, but I do cherish the time spent with them. My mother passed away in February from metastatic breast cancer (after a 23 year battle) and my father passed away just 14 weeks later from leukemia. I may be just a bit ahead of you in the warped timeline of grief, but your blog encapsulates so many of my thoughts – albeit in much better prose. A mix of sadness, frustration, guilt and also a sense of relief that neither of them is in pain anymore and there’s nothing more I can do. Like you, next month my brothers and I are spreading our parents ashes in the waters of one of our favorite places where we shared many happy days together as a family. Hang in there and keep writing.